MacCentral Week in Review

Editorial: A real sea tale
By David Leishman, dleishman@maccentral.com

Almost a thousand years ago, Canute the Great was the king of England, Denmark and Norway. As are most leaders, he was trailed by a retinue of hangers-on who praised him at every opportunity, often claiming that even supernatural feats were within his command.

Canute grew weary of the hype and decided to cut it short with a graphic demonstration of the limit of his powers. He had his chair placed at the edge of the sea, and as the tide rolled in, he commanded it to stop. No luck, of course, on stopping the tide, but Canute managed to gain a respite from the clamoring of the crowd.

Now, in the dawn of the 21st century, Apple's musical efforts have won the huzzahs of the media and a lot of citizens, and it holds a commanding lead in sales of digital music players and downloaded tunes. It's begun a creative licensing strategy that has made partners of corporate giants such as Hewlett Packard, Pepsi, and Motorola.

But, in the not too distant future, Microsoft will roll out its own digital music strategy, and, given its almost unlimited bankroll, will likely prove a formidable opponent for Apple.

In the meantime, however, RealNetworks is proving to be a real pain in Apple's side. In April, Real approached Apple about making the iPod compatible with Real's RealPlayer Music Store (RPMS). Request denied. This week Real announced the release of Harmony, a digital rights management translation service that will enable RPMS customers to play those songs on an iPod.

Apple has retaliated by claiming Real used "hacker" tactics to achieve its ends, threatening to invoke the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA) to cause Real to cease and desist, and darkly hinting that it has the means to ensure that Real's tunes "cease to work with current and future iPods."

Real responded to Apple's comments by claiming that. "Consumers, and not Apple, should be the ones choosing what music goes on their iPod."

Now, I've always found RealPlayer to be an unsatisfying piece of software, and over the years, I've had oodles of trouble with Microsoft's Windows Media Player. Whereas Apple's QuickTime media player has always performed quite nicely on my Macs, and Windows-using friends have generally applauded how it works on their machines. But even QT-hating Win-users don't advocate suing Apple for developing a client that runs on their machines.

I think Apple's got a unique set of problems to deal with, and I'm not sure that its current strategy is a winner. RealNetworks has the high ground when it claims that consumer choice is all-important. After all, we're not talking piracy here -- which Steve Jobs has claimed as the real enemy -- but rather competition, which is the spur of invention and, inevitably leads to more choice.

Apple needs to recognize, as Canute did, that it can't stop the tide, and get back to ruling its digital music kingdom wisely.

Apple News

RealNetworks "Harmony" ignites battle between Real and Apple

RealNetworks on Monday introduced Harmony technology, which it says is the first digital rights management translation service to allow users who buy music from the RealPlayer Music Store to play the music on other personal music devices, including the iPod. Apple on Thursday announced it was "stunned" that Real "adopted the tactics and ethics of a hacker to break into the iPod," is investigating the implications of their actions under the DMCA. Apple also warned RealNetworks and its users that the Harmony technology will likely not work in the future. Real subsequently reaffirmed its commitment to Harmony and noted, "Consumers, and not Apple, should be the ones choosing what music goes on their iPod."

Apple, Motorola to bring iTunes to cell phones

Apple CEO Steve Jobs told attendees of a Motorola event via satellite that Apple and Motorola Inc would partner to allow users to transfer iTunes music to their next generation mobile handsets. Apple will create an iTunes mobile music player, which will be standard on all of Motorola's mass-market music phones.

Alpine offers details on forthcoming iPod interface

Motorola posts iTunes announcement movie

Henrico turns down iBook lease renewal, for now

Long lines await iPod mini's Tokyo debut

Visit MacCentral's Apple Hardware and Apple Software forums.

Hardware News

ATI introduces Mobility Radeon 9800

Graphics card and chip maker ATI Technologies on Tuesday introduced its Mobility Radeon 9800, a new graphics solution aimed at laptops based on the same core technology that powers ATI's Radeon X800 line. It features eight pixel pipelines and a 256-bit wide memory interface. It also supports ATI's Smartshader HD and 3Dc, the most recent iterations of ATI's texture mapping technology, along with the latest generation of ATI's power management technology, called Powerplay.

Fuji intros five new digital cameras

WiebeTech 100GB ComboGB drive sports three interfaces

HD-DVD comes out fighting, launch in 2005

Iomega offers double layer DVD drive

Media 100 HD coming this fall with new features

Visit MacCentral's Hardware forum.

Software News

Rogue Amoeba releases Audio Hijack Pro 2.0

Rogue Amoeba on Wednesday introduced Audio Hijack Pro 2.0, a new version of their audio recording and enhancement utility that enables Mac users to capture any audio played on the Mac, and also apply VST and AudioUnit plug-ins to process the audio. New features include a revamped user interface, and the ability to record using Dolby Advanced Audio Codec (AAC) and Apple Lossless (ALAC) formats.

youPod lets you take Address Book, iCal, more with you

Quark enhances XTensions developer program, joins NGP

Aspyr to publish Mac Spider-Man 2 game in August

iShell 4 adds one-click deployment, more

'Fifty Gallon Drums' GarageBand loops available

Visit MacCentral's Software forum.

Around the Web

For Apple, Harmony Is off-key

BusinessWeek's Peter Burrows analyzes the coming battle between RealNetworks and Apple over the former's announced Harmony technology, which will enable consumers to play Real-formatted songs on iPods, and suggests Apple "should clearly and firmly squelch Real's attempt to infiltrate (its) music empire."

Apple and Motorola: Ringing and singing

Click Wheel iPod: More mini than Maxi?

Mossberg: Sony's new Walkman is no iPod killer

Ars Technica guide to PCI Express

LCD prices slide

Worship my radiant iPod

Battle brews over rules for phones on Internet

Visit MacCentral's Lounge forum.

Subscribe to the Best of Macworld Newsletter

Comments