MacCentral Week in Review

Editorial: Apple is tops at retail
By Peter Cohen, pcohen@maccentral.com

A recent survey published by PC World ranked Apple as the best brick-and-mortar retail computer buying experience. They compared shopping at the Apple Store to other major retailers where you can buy PCs -- Best Buy, Circuit City, CompUSA and Staples -- and Apple trounced the competition, nabbing an "Excellent" rating while everyone else ranked "Poor." It's especially noteworthy coming from a PC-centric publication (PC World's a member of our extended IDG family).

When you consider the one-size-fits-all mentality, lack of adequate sales training and warehouse-style settings at many major electronics retailers, perhaps Apple's success in this report isn't exactly a major surprise, but it's good news nonetheless as Apple continues to expand its retail presence at home and abroad. There's no question that the Apple retail stores have had a very positive effect both on Apple's bottom line and on its public perception. Apple's Q4 numbers won't be released until next week, but if its past performance is anything to go on, Apple's retail segment was responsible for about US$270 million of the more than $2 billion Apple took in during its third financial quarter, or more than 10 percent of its quarterly revenue.

Many of the people passing through Apple's stores are Windows users and first time PC buyers -- the positive effect that retail experience has on them cannot be discounted, even if they're just coming in the door to buy an iPod. So where does Apple go from here?

Apple says that the majority of the U.S. population is now within a fairly short drive of an Apple Store. Convenience for consumers is everything, but Apple Stores are still few and far between in many areas. I'm more than an hour's drive from my closest Apple store, and it's located in a busy urban setting I'd rather not deal with. I know I'm not alone -- I've talked with plenty of Mac enthusiasts in this area who may have visited the closest Apple store once, but haven't returned because of the hassle of actually getting there.

It makes sense that Apple must continue to expand the scope and penetration of its retail presence, but doing so has its own risks as well. Just ask PC maker Gateway, which beat a hasty retreat after opening up its own retail chain. Gateway overextended itself by opening locations that were just unprofitable, plain and simple. Apple seems anxious not to make the same mistake. Apple is taking a more cautious approach that demands bottom-line results.

Smaller venues may be one solution -- opening up "micro-stores" that only carry a select supply of Apple products, software and peripherals, manned by fewer salespeople, without as much of the operating overhead as Apple's bigger locations. Apple's already modulated the size of some of its retail spots depending on what real estate is available and what the local market can bear.

Ultimately, however, I don't expect that we'll see an Apple store or kiosk in every mall in the country. To that end, chains like Apple's competitors in PC World's survey still have a better reach, and one that they're likely to maintain. That's fine for iPods, but what about Macs? Apple's past experience working with the big chains to get Macs into consumers' hands has been rather disastrous.

Ultimately, peripheral regions like mine seem primarily to be the domain of the independent reseller and the mail order catalog and online reseller. Neither channel really sports the marketing muscle or the brand identity to draw customers with any particular fervor like the new opening of an Apple Store might, but they're still excellent resources to turn to. And while catalogers may have some brick and mortar stores beat on pricing, rebates or bundle deals, independent resellers remain, by and large, a great place to find personalized, face-to-face service that you'd be hard pressed to find somewhere else.

Apple News

Honeywell sues Apple, 33 others over LCD patent

Honeywell on Wednesday announced that it has filed suit against Apple and 33 other companies for alleged patent infringement over a technology that "increases the brightness of images and that reduces the appearance of certain interference effects on a liquid crystal display (LCD)," according to a statement.

Details emerge in Honeywell's suit against Apple

MacCentral has obtained a copy of the documents Honeywell filed on October 6, 2004 in U.S. District Court for the district of Delaware.

Apple releases Security Update 2004-09-30

Apple is 'clear winner' of PC World retail survey

Apple launches iMac G5 Troubleshooting Assistant

Power Mac G5s up for grabs in open source contest

VP debate now on iTunes

Visit MacCentral's Apple Hardware and Apple Software forums.

Hardware News

M-Audio releases O2 MIDI keyboard

M-Audio has introduced a new mobile MIDI USB controller that serves as the followup to the company's popular Oxygen8 controller. The US$179 O2 features 25 full-size, half-action velocity-sensitive keys, 8 assignable knobs and 8 assignable buttons, mod and pitch bend, input for a sustain pedal, and the ability to draw power from USB or off of a 9V adapter.

Griffin offers USB-based SecuriKey for Mac OS X

Sonnet adds USB 2 to Piccolo drives, drops prices

JVC unveils HDD digital still, video camera

Brother intros 4 SOHO multi-function printers

MacMice ships Bluetooth mouse

BTI's iPod Battery II offers 40 hours of music

PalmOne intros Tungsten T5 PDA

Visit MacCentral's Hardware forum.

Software News

Microsoft releases Virtual PC 7

First introduced on Jan. 6, 2004, Microsoft Corp.'s Macintosh Business Unit on Tuesday announced the release of Virtual PC 7 for the Mac. Among the many new features, company executives boast about a 10 percent to 30 percent increase in performance and support for Apple's Power Mac G5.

EarthLink offers VoIP service

RealPlayer 10 for OS X goes international

Iconfactory offers spooky Halloween icons

New DTS surround encoders leverage OS X, Xserve

Aspyr announces Men of Valor for Mac

Webstractor 1.1 adds new ways to edit Web pages

Visit MacCentral's Software forum.

Around the Web

Ballmer: 'No way' Apple will win digital media war

Microsoft CEO Steve Ballmer told invited press at a London briefing that Microsoft would prevail over Apple, Sony and other competitors when it comes to winning the hearts and minds of home consumers looking to integrate computer technology into their home entertainment systems. "There is no way you can get there with Apple," he is quoted as saying by Silicon.com.

Jobs back to work as Apple chief executive

AT&T looks into closing its Windows

iPod Dominates Teen Mindshare

Apple's server and storage offerings are helping the company overcome its reputation as the high-priced computing option

Cheap Macs from [Thai] gov't

Visit MacCentral's Lounge forum.

Subscribe to the Best of Macworld Newsletter

Comments