A Mac user's take on the Windows 7 user interface

Where Windows 7 beats the Mac OS X UI

Gadget sidebar: My favorite aspect of the Windows 7 UI is in fact a carryover from Vista: its gadget sidebar. With Windows 7, however, the sidebar is no longer displayed automatically. As such, your desktop is no longer partly obscured by "gadget" utilities that, quite frankly, you won't use often. Instead, you can toggle the gadget sidebar when you want it—just as you can with Mac OS X. And you can drag them out of the sidebar and let them free-float where you want. The big difference is that Mac OS X's sidebar equivalent covers your entire desktop, rendering everything else inaccessible, and the individual gadgets can't be pulled out of that covers-everything sidebar. The Windows 7 approach to gadgets shows the kind of elegance and simplicity that Microsoft needs to do more often.

Network and Sharing Center: Windows 7's new Network and Sharing Center provides a worthwhile visual cue as to your network's setup. It also includes straightforward setup tools to diagnose the network and switch location-specific configurations. Although it is easier to actually connect to other Mac users in Mac OS X than it is to connect to other PC users in Windows, the latter provides a better overall picture of your network state than the Mac OS does.

Window resizing: Another plus for Microsoft, Windows has long let users resize application and other windows by dragging any side. Mac OS X still forces you to use the lower-right corner, which the Dock sometimes obscures.

Dialog box actions: Although this breaks with Apple's purist mentality, I've always liked the fact that in Windows when I'm using an Open or Save dialog box I can rename or otherwise manipulate files and folders through that dialog box, without having to close the box and switch to Finder. Yes, I know that breaks the architectural line between applications and the OS, but it makes life easier. And, yes, I know you can usually create folders from apps' Save As dialog boxes on the Mac, but that's not enough.

Uninstall: The one big deficit in the Mac OS is its lack of a central way to uninstall applications and their support files. Although the Windows uninstall doesn't always clean up everything, the Mac provides no facility for finding and removing these stray files. They don't seem to do harm, but why leave them around?

Where Mac OS X and Windows 7 even out

Security warnings—or lack thereof: Windows 7 reduces the UAC security nagging of Vista, putting it on par with XP and Mac OS X. I really noticed the difference, so I rarely canceled an action I wanted because of incessant, confusing security warnings—a frequent problem in Vista.

Taskbar vs. Dock: Windows 7's taskbar works more like the Mac OS X dock, making the "pinned" (docked) applications more visible than the XP/Vista taskbar's quick-launch icons. Plus, they animate when opening, copying a concept from the Mac OS Dock. (In what I assume was a beta bug, the taskbar's pinned icons appeared only after I dragged an application onto the taskbar to pin it there; using the Pin to Taskbar contextual menu didn't toggle on their display in the taskbar.) Beyond the strictly visual design, the biggest difference between the Windows 7 taskbar and the Mac OS X dock is that you can add status controls, such as checking on available networks, to the taskbar. In the Mac OS X, such controls reside in the taskbar at the edge of the application bar, not in the Dock. Either way, you get quick access to essentially the same things. And the stacks capability for displaying folder contents in the Mac OS X Dock is more customizable in terms of its display than Windows' equivalent.

File and folder navigation: The file-and-folder approach to navigating storage media is essentially the same in Mac OS and Windows, and both Mac OS X and Windows 7 (like Vista) let you put your favorite directories into the easy-access lists in the folder windows, as well as offer quick-look file previews. I've always liked Mac OS' ability to let you color folders, as a visual mnemonic; Windows can't do this, but a lot of Mac users don't use it, either.

Overall, Windows 7 does not yet present a clear step away from Vista in terms of user experience. There are some nice UI enhancements, but nothing to undo the learning curve necessary to transition from XP. Then again, at least it hasn't gotten worse—a real possibility given what Microsoft has done to Internet Explorer and Office.

Former Macworld editor Galen Gruman is the executive editor for news and features at InfoWorld.

Subscribe to the MacWeek Newsletter

Comments