Understanding Wi-Fi's two spectrum bands

The evolution of communications is about taking one kind of thing and making it better, faster, and more reliable. USB 1 evolved into USB 2; FireWire 400 morphed into FireWire 800; 10 Mbps Ethernet moved into 100 Mbps and then 1,000 Mbps. Where there’s a choice, it’s between a worse, older alternative and the latest and greatest.

Not so with Wi-Fi, which has an interesting current tradeoff with Apple’s implementation in hardware and software. You’re given a significant choice as to which spectrum band to use or whether to let Mac OS X decide for you. The choice you make has a huge impact on the distance, robustness, and speed you can eke out of a network without wires.

Wi-Fi can work over one of two spectrum bands: 2.4GHz or 5GHz. The two bands have quite different properties, and in the past Apple’s AirPort Base Stations have only been able to use one band at a time. But the AirPort Base Station and Time Capsules released in March 2009 can operate simultaneously over both bands, removing some of the difficulty of building Wi-Fi networks that work best for whatever devices we attach to them.

Apple also supports both bands in Macs and the Apple TV as network clients. Nearly all Macs with Intel processors work in both bands, while nearly all Core 2 Duo Macs (and Mac Pros with Wi-Fi) also handle the latest 802.11n Wi-Fi spec. (First-generation Intel Macs have dual-band support, but only for an older standard in 5GHz.)

With all this dual-band support, Apple has tried to keep you from having to make a decision about which band to use, automatically choosing the right frequencies for speed, consistency, and range based on where your computer is relative to a base station at any given time.

Often, taking Apple’s suggestions makes the most sense, but other times, you want to override automatic selection and other options to produce better, more consistent throughput and range. I’ll look at common problems and solutions that might plague you in the 2.4GHz and 5GHz bands, and then offer advice for manually setting channels in both bands or creating two unique networks with a simultaneous dual-band base station.

Band tradeoffs

Wireless networks work by having a wireless base station transmit data on a given range of frequencies to another device. Both of the frequency bands used by Apple’s base stations are unlicensed, which means any individual or organization can build a device that sends signals in the frequency range covered by the band without obtaining permission.

Unlicensed bands require that devices generate no unnecessary interference—meaning they use as little signal as is necessary to communicate. (What we think of as interference turns out to be other signals that your particular receiving device doesn’t want to hear.) Equipment that works in these bands must also be resistant to interference, able to cope with unwanted signals in order to sort out the information it wants to extract.

The tradeoffs between 2.4GHz and 5GHz have to do with interference (almost entirely in 2.4GHz), range, and speed, three properties that all relate to one another. The more interference, the less speed and range; the greater range you want, the less speed you can have; the greater speed you want, the more you have to mitigate interference and work closer to an access point.

Let’s break down the band problems by these categories to see what you can do to affect each related property:

Interference in 2.4 GHz: The 2.4GHz band is a “junk” band—it’s a frequency range that’s heavily polluted. It’s one of the most heavily used industrial, scientific, and medical (ISM) bands, which have broad rules to allow equipment that needs to emit a signal to work in within its confines. ISM devices aren’t used for communication, but produce electromagnetic signals as part of their operation. And those signals are interference.

The 2.4GHz band also has a host of other competing uses; 5GHz has the distinct benefit of having very little technology that makes use of the band. Reducing interference lets networks work at higher speeds and greater ranges.

Let’s look through common 2.4 GHz interference problems. (Also see “Troubleshooting AirPort Interference,” a 2007 article which is a little out of date on some topics, but has more general advice.)

Problem: Your home or office microwave oven. It uses the 2.4GHz band to heat water molecules, warming your food. A microwave oven contains a device that generates a roughly 1,000-watt signal oscillating 2.4 billion times a second—2.4GHz. And there’s your interference. Microwaves are shielded from emissions, but that only reduces the vast majority. There are tiny leakages that, while nearly unmeasurable, are still enough to disrupt Wi-Fi, which uses very low signal levels.

Solution: Stop making popcorn already! And move your base station farther from your kitchen or breakroom. Or use the 5GHz band, which lacks all these interference sources.

Problem: Networking hardware and the 2.4GHz band. The band shares uses with common purposes, such as Bluetooth, cordless phones, baby monitors, and video cameras. Bluetooth has been harmonized and coordinated with Wi-Fi for years, but other devices aren’t so pleasant. The British spectrum regulator OFCOM just released a study that showed interference from competing devices, especially wireless cameras and baby monitors, appeared to be responsible for most Wi-Fi interference, at least in London.

Solution: Update your gear, switching to 5.8GHz phones or better behaved baby monitors (some use Wi-Fi directly now), or force your Wi-Fi clients to use 5GHz, if that’s an option.

Problem: Few non-overlapping channels. To make matters—and the potential for interference—worse, the 2.4GHz band is divided into overlapping channels. The more overlap, the greater the interference among networks located closely together. In the U.S., that means that only channels 1, 6, and 11 are mostly in the clear when used in proximity. In an urban area or apartment building you might see dozens of networks all trying to use the same frequencies, and all colliding off each other—Wi-Fi doesn’t give one user’s network preference to another—reducing throughput and sometimes causing the network to drop.

The 2.4 GHz bands uses staggered, overlapping channels, which provides few clear options. The 5 GHz band reserves a full channel width without overlap.

Solution: This will sound repetitive, but switching to 5GHz alleviates the channel problem. (I’ll talk about how to force newer 802.11n hardware to use 5GHz later in this article.) That’s because so many more channels are available—and without any overlap—in the 5GHz band. (Channel availability varies by country, more in 5GHz than 2.4GHz; Apple has a list.)

 

Range: The big advantage 2.4GHz has over 5GHz is range. The shorter wavelengths used in the 5GHz band cannot penetrate as well through seemingly solid objects like walls, ceilings, desks, and people. The flip side is that 5GHz has different rules about how much power a base station can use to send signals.

Problem: 5GHz range seems quite small compared to 2.4GHz. You can go one room away and not get a strong 5GHz signal or see a network set to 5GHz.

Solution: In all likelihood, the base station automatically chose a low-numbered 5 GHz channel (or you chose it manually). In the U.S., the lower four available 5 GHz channels can only transmit at 5 percent of the power of the higher channels. Apple’s new base stations now automatically choose a higher-numbered channel by default if there’s one available. If your station is choosing a lower channel in the 5GHz band, you may want to override that choice and choose a higher channel manually in order to get the signal strength you deserve.

You can override this by using AirPort Utility and forcing a choice:

  1. Launch AirPort Utility, select your base station, and click on Manual Setup.
  2. Click on the AirPort icon and then on the Wireless tab.
  3. Select Manual from the Radio Channel Selection menu.
  4. Note the channel displayed, such as 36 (5 GHz). If the channel number is from 36 to 48, click on the Edit button.
  5. Select a higher-numbered channel, starting at 149.

(These instructions are for a simultaneous dual-band base station. For a one-band-at-a-time 802.11n base station, hold down the Option key and then click on Channel in step 3, and then select the channel from the pop-up menu that appears. Radio Mode must be set to “802.11n (802.11a compatible)” or “802.11n only (5GHz)” for 5GHz channel options to appear on those 802.11n base stations.)

With the channel selection set to Automatic, the base station may be avoiding a higher-numbered channel because of interference, although that should be unlikely. If you choose 149 or higher and have problems with your network, try the other three options in succession (153, 157, and 161), and if you still have trouble, switch back to automatic and see if problems go away.

Speed: There’s one more variable in the mix—speed, more properly measured as throughput, or the actual amount of data that can be carried over a medium whether radio waves or wire. Wi-Fi’s speed drops by increments the further you are from a base station with a client adapter in a computer or handheld, or when interference prevents signals from being cleanly received.

Problem: Slow connection speeds. When checking with AirPort Utility (see Check your Wi-Fi speeds), an 802.11n device is connecting in 5 GHz at 130 Mbps or slower.

Solution: Make sure wide channels are enabled. With 802.11n, a Wi-Fi base station can create a connection over a wide channel, which uses twice the frequency range as a regular channel. Apple and some other makers opted against allowing wide channels in 2.4GHz, because there’s already so much interference it might have only muddied signals further.

In 5GHz, however, where interference is much lower and channels more numerous, Apple automatically enables wide channels. Check that this option has been turned on, if you’re not seeing rates up to 270 Mbps, the highest raw data rates.

  1. Launch AirPort Utility, select your base station, and click on Manual Setup.
  2. Click on the AirPort icon and then on the Wireless tab.
  3. Click on the Wireless Options button.
  4. Make sure that Use Wide Channels is checked.
  5. If not, check the box, click Done, and click Update to restart the base station.

Problem: Low data rates. Specifically, when you look in AirPort Utility, you notice low data rates in either or both the 2.4GHz and 5GHz bands.

Solution: If your base station is far away from where your clients are connecting, see if you can move it closer, or add a second base station that extends the network.

Also check for interference. If removing potential sources or moving the base station away from possible sources improves speeds, that’s your problem (and your solution).

Tweaking band choices

Apple does as much as possible to make good default choices with Wi-Fi, but there are cases where you need to tweak the settings. You may want to set a channel manually, and you may want to split your 2.4GHz and 5GHz networks on a simultaneous dual-band base station into two unique networks.

By default with its new simultaneous dual-band base stations, Apple has both bands active (two separate radios sending separate network signals) using the same network name (its SSID or service set identifier).

On the client side, with Mac OS X 10.5.6 or later and the AirPort Client Update 2009-001 installed, your Mac uses a variety of techniques to evaluate whether it should connect to the 2.4GHz or 5GHz version of the same network if the network’s named the same.

Leopard looks at network signal strength for the network it’s on and same-named networks in the vicinity. When performance or signal strength drops, Leopard evaluates whether it’s better off to go further with 2.4GHz or try to stay faster with 5GHz.

This pairing of two bands and client hardware that picks the optimum band often works best. But there are three reasons that you might want to have separately-named networks for each band.

While the latest version of Leopard is smart about which band it chooses, older versions of Mac OS X and hardware from other companies that can work on either band uses less clever methodology. Choosing 2.4GHz might result in a very slow or erratic link when the signal strength is stronger, because network congestion and interference aren’t measured in 2.4GHz when Leopard chooses to switch over.

Another reason would be to keep some devices off of your 5GHz band, forcing 802.11n clients to use 5GHz exclusively. This frees up room in the 2.4GHz band and guarantees faster speeds for 802.11 devices. For example, most Intel Core Duo Macs can use the 802.11a standard. (The faster 802.11n standard arrived with Core 2 Duo-based Macs.) If you have an older 802.11a/b/g device, you might want to sequester it on the 2.4GHz band in order to prevent it from reducing the speed of your 802.11n-based 5GHz network.

Likewise, you might want to make sure your newest gear only uses 5GHz and never dips down into 2.4GHz. Apple tries to switch to 2.4GHz only when it’s necessary—say, the signal performance fades below an optimum level—but you might prefer to see the lag and move closer rather than drop into a crowded band.

Check the box to set a separate name for the 5 GHz network, allowing you to force which devices connect to which band.

To split the bands in two:

  1. Launch AirPort Utility, select your base station, and click on Manual Setup.
  2. Click on the AirPort icon and then on the Wireless tab.
  3. Click on the Wireless Options button.
  4. Check the 5GHz Network Name box, and provide a new name for the 5GHz network.
  5. Click on the Done button and then on the Update button. All other wireless options remain the same, including encryption.

There’s an alternate way to use AirPort Utility to keep 802.11a/b/g devices from connecting to your network on the 5GHz band: In the Wireless tab’s Radio Mode pop-up menu, you can reveal extra choices for what standards are supported in each spectrum band by holding down the Option key and clicking on the menu.

Removing 802.11a compatibility from 5 GHz restricts 802.11a-only devices from slowing down your faster band.

By default, full backwards compatibility is chosen: 802.11b/g/n for 2.4 GHz and 802.11a/n for 5GHz. Instead, choose “802.11n only (5 GHz) - 802.11b/g/n” to disable 802.11a in 5GHz.

Clear signals ahead

Learning what makes each band tick makes it more likely that you’ll be able to create a network that’s robust and fast, working consistently without dropouts or drops in speed.

[Glenn Fleishman writes constantly about networking, mostly wireless, and is the author of Take Control of Your 802.11n AirPort Network (Take Control Ebooks).]

recommended for you

Time Capsule

Read more »

Subscribe to the Apple @ Work Newsletter

Comments