capsule review

Maxthon 1.0 browser is fast, has roots in Chrome

At a Glance
  • Maxthon International Maxthon for Mac 1.0.3

    Macworld Rating

Maxthon 1.0.3, a browser made in China that has made it to the U.S. and the Mac, is a blisteringly fast, undeniably slick way to navigate the web.

It’s also Google Chrome—well, mostly Google Chrome, or at least its open-source sibling Chromium. Nods to Mozilla, WebKit, Darwin, and seemingly every other open-source browser framework also show up in the program’s documentation.

Your Roots Are Showing: Maxthon doesn’t try too hard to disguise the great chunks of its code that come from Google’s Chromium.

Maxthon doesn’t try to conceal its origins. From the look, feel, and usability of the bookmarks bar, to the option to open a “new Incognito window,” to the distinctive arrow graphics that appear at the edges of a page when you navigate forward or back, Maxthon might as well be Chrome. One dialog box even refers to a menu with a wrench icon—a feature in Chrome that appears nowhere in Maxthon’s reskinned interface. (To its credit, Maxthon’s about box has the courtesy to credit its Chromium origins.)

Everything you know from Chrome (and a lot you’ll find in Safari 6 ( ) is here in Maxthon, including a handy unified search/URL bar, tabbed browsing, the exact same developer tools, and an options menu at the top right of the window. Maxthon has its own My Maxthon synching system for bookmarks and passwords, though you’ll need to hand over an email address to sign up.

So why should you even bother with a browser that’s basically Chrome with a facelift? Maxthon offers several reasons, but not all of them are equally compelling.

Zip! Zing! Zoom!

Maxthon promises a fast browsing experience, and on this count, it absolutely delivers. HTML text on pages renders in less time than it takes to blink, and images and other features appear as quickly as your connection will allow. Full support for OS X gesture controls lets you scroll and swipe through the web with impressive grace. I don’t know whether I’ve used a Mac browser that feels faster than Maxthon.

Not Quite There Yet: Though the PC version of Maxthon posts impressive HTML5 standards compliance, the Mac version (at left) falls considerably short

Maxthon also offers extensions, although only six were available for the Mac as of this writing. I tried out a Facebook status extension, which installed fine, but only displayed an endless loading indicator when I tried to use it. Again, the browser doesn’t even try to hide its debt to Chrome; on the page where you download extensions, the graphic for AdBlock declares it “the most popular extension for Chrome.”

Maxthon also tries to bring in the Reader feature from Safari, turning multi-page articles into a single coherent reading experience. Alas, here this feature is somehow even more broken than it was when it first appeared in Safari 5—no mean feat. I couldn’t get Maxthon’s Reader to load more than the first page of any article; in some cases where it should have appeared, the option to turn it on didn’t show up at all.

Many of the more elaborate features in the PC version of Maxthon haven’t yet arrived on the Mac, but it does handle the basics more than competently. I had no trouble with Netflix streaming, QuickTime movies, or any other usual browsing task. Perhaps thanks to its Chromium code, Maxthon worked beautifully with WebGL 3D demos. And it implements an Opera- and Safari-style grid of popular sites in new tabs far better than the latest version of Firefox.

Extensions: Some of the Maxthon extensions seem entirely borrowed from Chrome.

The numbers? Not bad

In benchmark tests on a 2GHz aluminum MacBook with 2GB of RAM, Maxthon performed quite respectably in some tests, but lagged curiously in others, especially in several tests where Chrome smoked the competition.

Maxthon’s PC version posts one of HTML5Test.com’s highest scores for compliance with the latest Web standards. But the Mac version—at least on my Mac—beat only Firefox, trailing Safari and Opera ( ), and left far in the dust by Chrome. It did, however, ace the Acid3 standards test, like every browser save Firefox.

Maxthon beat all comers in HTML5 bitmap graphics performance, edging out Opera and Safari. (This may explain its superb speed when loading pages.) However, it placed dead last for HTML5 text handling, and came in fourth out of five browsers in HTML5 vector graphics. Its score there roughly equaled Chrome’s, but came in at around half of Safari’s results.

In two JavaScript tests, Maxthon posted mixed numbers. It placed fourth in the SunSpider benchmark, only slightly edging out Opera, and light-years behind Chrome’s winning score. Chrome also won Google’s own V8 benchmark suite, and while Maxthon came in second overall there, it ran almost 20 percent slower. Given all the code Maxthon borrowed from Chrome, you’d think it could have helped itself to more of that browser’s bleeding-edge JavaScript engine.

Benchmarks: Maxthon 1.0.3

BrowserHTML5 VectorHTML5 BitmapHTML5 TextV8SunSpiderAcid3HTML5 Compliance
Maxthon 1.0.3 15.57 56.08 17.14 5799 390.8 100 385/9 bonus
Safari 6.0 34.53 55.05 20.39 4575 353.7 100 391/11 bonus
Opera 12 25.22 55.98 20.17 2323 393.3 100 400/9 bonus
Firefox 14.0.1 2.86 13.65 19.29 3827 338.8 97 345/9 bonus
Chrome 21 15.59 45.92 18.33 7301 332.1 100 437/13 bonus

Best results in bold. Reference browsers are in italics. HTML5 Vector, Bitmap, and Text test results are in frames per second; higher is better. The V8 Benchmark Suite test results are scores; higher is better. The SunSpider JavaScript results are in milliseconds; shorter times are better. The Acid3 result is a score out of 100. HTML5 Compliance is a score out of 500.

Bottom line

Maxthon’s perfectly fine for anything you’d want to do on the Web, and it definitely feels at least a bit faster than any other browser. But its rough edges and clear debts to other browsers make it feel more like a hastily assembled knockoff than a bold new challenger. It has the potential to be a terrific browser, but for now, it’s clearly—and somewhat shakily— standing on the shoulders of giants.

[Nathan Alderman is a writer, editor, and appreciator of originality in Alexandria, Va.]

To comment on this article and other Macworld content, visit our Facebook page or our Twitter feed.
At a Glance
  • Macworld Rating

    Pros

    • Renders pages in a flash
    • Everything works more or less as it should

    Cons

    • Iffy extension support
    • Reader mode broken
    • Assembled from bits of other browsers
Notice to our Readers
We're now using social media to take your comments and feedback. Learn more about this here.