HP Color LaserJet Pro M177fw review: Great output, but little else

hp color laserjet  pro m177fw jan 2014
At a Glance
  • HP Color LaserJet Pro MFP M177fw

    PCWorld Rating

    This color laser multifunction printer offers the usual compromises for this bargain price range: slow performance, minimal features, and high toner costs. If you don't print much then you might not mind...

HP makes some very capable, feature-rich color laser multifunction printers. The HP Color LaserJet Pro M177fw isn't one of them. It actually has impressive output quality, however, its low purchase price brings compromises in speed, features, and toner costs. Unless you print very little, you will come to spend far more on this product than you'd probably like. 

Design and features

The M177fw may be attached via USB, 10/100 Ethernet, or Wi-Fi. Setup was easy in my hands-on and the driver dialog is nicely laid out with the ability to create shortcuts for your most often used settings. The HTML management pages for checking on the printer across the network were also easy to use. HP provides capable software for all the MFP basics, as well as the now-usual array of remote and Internet printing options.

The M177fw has a 3-inch touchscreen display that makes it easy to operate. Paper capacity is limited (though in line with the low-volume, 250- to 950-page recommended monthly usage for this product). There's a 150-page, open-faced input tray, a 50-page output tray, and a 35-page automatic document feeder (which was very noisy on our test unit). There's no automatic duplex copying, printing, or scanning. HP provides assistance for manual-duplex printing, but none for two-sided scanning or copying.

The scanner lid doesn't telescope, even slightly. Even most non-telescoping lids have slight give in their hinges, but the M177fw's lid canted upward even when scanning a mere 100-page magazine.

Output quality and performance

The M177fw's overall output quality is a highlight. Photos are rendered exceptionally well for a laser printer, with little graininess and a cool, but still attractive palette. Text and monochrome graphics are equally outstanding—sharp and black. An econo-mode which saves a lot of toner, but still produces legible text. When you see the toner costs, you'll see the need for it.

The M177fw has the slower performance that's typical of low-cost color lasers. Text and monochrome pages exit at 9.9 pages per minute on the PC, and 7.7 pages per minute on the Mac. Snapshot-sized, 4-inch by 6-inch photos print at just under 2 per minute to plain paper, and 1.5 per minute to glossy laser stock. A full-page photo exits in about 55 seconds. Copies proceed at about 4 per minute, and scans speeds are equally acceptable.

Expensive toner

With most office printers, higher-capacity cartridges can save you money. Not so with the M177fw. The only available supplies are the $55, 1300-page black and $58, 1000-page 130A series, forcing you to live with 4.2-cent black pages, and 21.6-cent four-color pages. The latter is a real ouch. The M177fw ships with 500-page starter cartridges, so you'll be feeling the pinch sooner, too.

By way of comparison, $500 color laser MFPs usually offer black pages for under 3 cents and four-color pages for under 15 cents with high-capacity supplies. Business-class Inkjet MFPs using high-capacity supplies—and costing about the same as the M177fw—run you less than 2 cents per page for black, and 7 cents per page for color.

The cartridges are mounted on a carousel inside the printer. To access a cartridge, you press an icon of the cartridge in the supplies menu on the control panel. It would be fun to watch, but unfortunately the hatch has to be closed while rotating.

Bottom line

There's no disparaging the LaserJet Pro M177fw's output—it's top notch. But as with all color-laser products at this price point, the toner is too expensive, and the features are just adequate. We suggest you start at the $500 level if you really want a color laser MFP. The toner will still be expensive, but at least there will be duplexing and more capacity.

If you're truly stuck shopping at the $300 level, a  business-class inkjet MFP is the better option, offering better speed, features, and output quality. 

This story, "HP Color LaserJet Pro M177fw review: Great output, but little else" was originally published by PCWorld.

To comment on this article and other Macworld content, visit our Facebook page or our Twitter feed.
At a Glance
  • PCWorld Rating

    This color laser multifunction printer offers the usual compromises for this bargain price range: slow performance, minimal features, and high toner costs. If you don't print much then you might not mind all of this. Otherwise, a like-priced business inkjet model would be a much better deal—or spending $500 or more for a color-laser model with better attributes.

    Pros

    • Impressive print quality
    • Easy-to-use touchscreen control panel

    Cons

    • Slow performance
    • Meager paper handling and no duplexing
    • Expensive toner
Notice to our Readers
We're now using social media to take your comments and feedback. Learn more about this here.