4 reasons why you should run your own Mac server, and 4 reasons why you shouldn't
Running a Mac server isn't for everyone, but it can be useful. Jason Snell breaks down the reasons why you should consider it, and why you should skip it.
I think I’ve had a Mac running as a server in my house continuously for nearly 20 years. Over the years, the hardware has changed—at least four times, so far as I can remember—and the tasks required of it have changed dramatically, too. But despite all that change, the presence of a server in my house has always been useful.
Then again, running a Mac server isn’t for everyone—and these days, network-attached storage (NAS) devices can provide most of the functionality of a computer at a lower cost and reduced complexity. What I’m saying is, it’s complicated
Why have a home server?
It can be very convenient to have a computer that’s always available. Let’s say you have a large collection of media files—music or videos—that you want to have available to play on your stereo or TV.
If there’s a big enough disk attached to that computer, it can also be the place you stash old files—especially if you’re using a newer Mac that’s got a smaller flash drive rather than a bigger spinning disk drive.
And if you use an online backup service, such as CrashPlan or Backblaze, you can back up that Mac and all of your precious files will be backed up, too.
Finally, if your home Internet service is slow, spotty, or metered, having a home server allows you to stock up on content—especially music and movies—and have them available to watch on a moment’s notice. Not everyone can stream HD movies with impunity.
Reasons to use a Mac server
Familiarity: If you’re a Mac user, you know how to use a Mac. You probably know how to share files and folders, run iTunes, the works. NASes don’t run OS X. You have to administer them from a webpage and if there’s trouble, you will be entering a world of troubleshooting that can get alien and frustrating in a hurry.
Availability: One of the best sources of Mac server hardware is an old Mac you already own. My first two Mac servers were both hand-me-down Power Macs. Once I got a fresher model, the old one went in the closet and served me for a few more years as my server. You can put an old iMac, Mac mini, or even laptop into service as a server with little or no financial investment.
Compatibility: If you want to serve protected iTunes content—TV shows and movies—to Macs, iOS devices, or an Apple TV, a Mac running iTunes somewhere on your network is the only official way to do that. Also, a lot of software and hardware is designed to work with computers, not storage devices.
Flexibility: Apple is constantly upgrading OS X, and most modern hardware comes along for the ride. Apps are constantly being updated to take advantage of new features. My home weather station came with some weird Java-based software that was never updated and worked horribly; I was able to easily replace it with a much better piece of native Mac software.
Embedded systems like NASes are harder to update and can be abandoned by their makers after a short time in favor of newer models.
Reasons not to use a Mac server
Price: You can get an impressively specced two-disk Synology array from Amazon for $263, for example. A four-disk model is $450. That’s cheaper than the cheapest Mac. If you don’t have a Mac appropriate to be tasked as a server, you can save a lot of money by just buying a NAS.
Energy: Running a Mac server all the time, especially if it’s attached to external hard drives, can use a lot of power. Most modern NAS devices are designed to be power efficient. I haven’t measured, but I’d imagine that I would use a lot less energy if I dumped my Drobo and Mac mini duo and replaced it with a single low-power NAS.
An extra device: If you’ve got a Mac you tend to use most of the time, you could make it your “household server” by leaving it on all the time, rather than dedicating an additional device. Or just remember to turn it on when you want to watch videos or listen to music.
More junk: You can run a Mac without any keyboard or monitor attached, in which case your server can take up very little space. But if you’ve got, say, an iMac, you’re stuck with the big screen. You’ve got to stick it somewhere, and it’s just another thing cluttering up your house.
All in all, I’m glad I’ve got a Mac server in my house. If I were starting from scratch today, I might consider a NAS—but I suspect that it wouldn’t be compatible with everything I use my Mac for, especially connecting to my home weather station. Either way, it’s awfully convenient to keep a server around—which is why, 20 years after I started, I’ve still got one.