Siri-ous mistakes: Apple's personal assistant still needs a lot of work

Siri performs well in Apple’s ads, but in real life, it’s a different story.

siri ios 9 stock

Siri, Apple’s voice-controlled virtual assistant, can be a wonderful tool. It can tell me what time it is, what the weather’s going to be, and even perform some basic calculations. I can use it to set an alarm, start a timer, or open an app.

But beyond those simple tasks, Apple’s virtual assistant doesn’t make the grade for me. And I’m not alone; Siri fails for a lot of people, even for simple questions.

Apple touts Siri as a miraculous tool that can simplify your life and turn your iPhone into a personal butler. But it doesn’t always work that way. It works fairly well with calendar events and emails, sends text messages efficiently, and calls people (if it understands their names).

Siri is one of those features that looks good in Apple’s ads, but that doesn’t always perform as it should. For example, it can perform simple math—what’s 15 percent of $37—but for more complex calculations, it gets addled. Here’s an example; I needed this calculation when I moved to a new house a couple of months ago:

geometry

Siri isn’t good at geometry.

Siri is good at snark, though, and the internet is rife with Siri’s tetchy answers. For example, try and divide something by zero, and Siri, rather than just give an answer, gets smart:

zero

A simple answer would be fine.

Siri is supposed to be good at sports-related information. And it can tell me who won last night’s game by a given team, but it can’t handle schedules very well. Here are two examples.

jets

I know the next Jets game isn’t for a while, but still...


olympics

It’s the Olympics this week, but Siri doesn’t seem to realize that there are dozens of sports.

A lot of Siri information is location-dependent. Ask for a restaurant, a bar, or a train station, and Siri should find your nearest places. I live just outside of Stratford-Upon-Avon, and Siri seems a bit confused about where I am.

movies

All these movies are “a bit far from Stratford-Upon-Avon;” they’re playing in Stratford-Upon-Avon...

And I asked where there were theaters nearby. Again, Siri didn’t think that the theaters in this town were in this town.

theaters

Perhaps Stratford-Upon-Avon has a doppelgänger.

Perhaps Siri—or my iPhone—doesn’t know where I am? No. If I ask how I get to Stratford-Upon-Avon, it shows me directions.

directions

My iPhone knows exactly where I am.

What if I ask some questions about, say, buying an iPhone, or getting accessories for my phone? Siri directs me to the nearest Apple Store (17 miles away), tells me to check Apple’s website, but for the rest? Serious failure.

cable

I’m not going that far for a cable.

case

I don’t think those places sell iPhone cases.

So what about tourism? Say I’m visiting Stratford-Upon-Avon, a town with a famous son who attracts millions of tourists. Siri thinks I’m still in Kansas:

kansas

No, Toto, we’re not in Kansas anymore.

And if I want to see Hamlet, which happens to be playing at the local theater this evening? Um...

shakespeare

And I asked where I can get a beer, and Siri ignored the three pubs that are within walking distance of me, instead telling me to go three miles to Stratford-Upon-Avon.

been

Sometimes I just want to get a beer.

The thing is, a simple Google search in Safari gets just about all of these questions right. Even the hypotenuse. Whereas Siri is good at snark, but not very good at finding useful information. And I’m not alone; lots of people report this kind of failure. It’s not that “I’m saying it wrong,” it’s simply that Siri isn’t as useful as Apple would like us to believe.

Apple has recorded all the questions people ask, and should be able to use this to fix Siri.

no comment

Even Siri knows that things aren’t as rosy as they could be.

To comment on this article and other Macworld content, visit our Facebook page or our Twitter feed.
Shop Tech Products at Amazon
Notice to our Readers
We're now using social media to take your comments and feedback. Learn more about this here.