Solution: I’m quite partial to SmugMug, and here’s why: Its algorithms for displaying images at different sizes show photos at their best.
Yes, there are better sites for community, such as Flickr, Picasa or Photo.net, but SmugMug’s chosen niche is actual photo display. That’s what first attracted me to the site, back in the days when I was hand-coding my own photo album pages and manually resizing pictures for thumbnails and Web-friendly larger versions.
Resizing is an art—certain settings will make a photo look better than others when its dimensions change. I’m impressed by the way various sizes of photos appear on SmugMug.
And I do mean various sizes: The site gives you links to eight different versions of each photo, and you can control the size of the picture you’d like visitors to see. “We even auto-adjust the image to fit the size of the visitors’ monitor/Web browser window so they get the best experience with the largest images possible,” one of SmugMug’s support staff e-mailed in explanation.
SmugMug offers some elegant tools for sharing. The site automatically creates embed code for small, medium and large versions of each photo—both HTML and BBCode (used for forum and blog comments)—that you can easily copy and use elsewhere. There’s also a wizard for generating RSS feed URLs.
SmugMug had power users in mind when it developed its tools for creating galleries (which SmugMug calls albums). In addition to a conventional gallery where you upload photos directly, you can create “smart galleries” that include or exclude photos based on rules. Those rules can include characteristics such as keyword tag, geography (SmugMug supports geotagging), date taken or date uploaded. Add another photo later that meets a gallery’s criteria and it will automatically be included in that gallery, even if you manually sent it somewhere else; upload once, and a photo can appear in numerous other galleries automatically.
You can also “collect” photos from your friends’ SmugMug galleries (or any photos that have been made publicly available) into a gallery of your own, where they’ll display with the appropriate credits and links back to the originating galleries. (Account holders can turn off collecting capabilities on their own accounts.)
There are some community tools within SmugMug as well: voting images up or down, commenting and the now-obligatory Twitter and Facebook buttons.
Galleries can be made public, “unlisted” or password-protected. You can group a number of unlisted galleries together into a “sharegroup,” so it’s simple to send a single link to several private galleries.
There are also a fair number of user-created apps, such as plug-ins for Adobe Lightroom and Apple’s iPhoto, and tool kits for a range of programming platforms such as Java, .Net, PHP, Python and Ruby. SmugMug encourages this work by offering a top-of-the-line Pro account free for a year if you code a public app using the SmugMug API.
SmugMug’s viewer interface isn’t always easy for newcomers looking at photos for the first time—for example, the slideshow button can be hard to spot at first glance. However, it’s certainly no more difficult to figure out than Facebook.
If your number one priority for photo sharing is finding and building community, SmugMug may not be your best option. Likewise if you’re looking for the lowest prices on prints and photo gifts—in that case, you might want to shop elsewhere. But if you’re interested in showing photos off to their best advantage, SmugMug is definitely worth a look.
$40 to $150 a year (free 14-day trial); SmugMug.com, SmugMug Inc.
[Sharon Machlis is online managing editor at Computerworld. Her e-mail address is email@example.com. You can follow her on Twitter @sharon000]