It wasn’t hard to figure out which company was on the minds of most of the attendees at the Music 2.0 conference in Los Angeles Wednesday. Whether representing record labels or online retailers, speakers at the digital music confab couldn’t praise Apple enough for the success enjoyed by the company’s iTunes Music Store — that is, when those same speakers weren’t predicting the store would soon tumble from its spot at the head of the online music market.
But talking about toppling the iTunes Music Store is one thing; actually doing it is another. And a little more than 18 months after its debut, the online music store continues to best all rivals. Chris Bush, director of product marketing for Apple, told conference attendees that the music store enjoys a 70 percent share of the market for legal music downloads.
With the extension of service to Europe and Canada, Apple is “now covering 65 percent of the global music market,” Bell said. “There’s no evidence of a slowdown or a plateau.”
Apple is “the groundbreaking and pacesetting company” in digital music, said Michael Stroud, CEO of iHollywood Forum, which organizes the Music 2.0 event.
But competitors think they’ve found an approach to online music that could knock Apple off its stride — subscription-based services.
“It’s the ultimate jukebox, being able to listen to everything and sample things without having to buy,” said Laura Goldberg, chief operating officer at Napster.
Downloads Vs. Subscriptions
Apple’s approach to online music sales is an a la carte model — it charges users a specific fee (usually 99 cents for a single download or $9.99 for a complete album) for whatever music they download. Other services, including Napster and RealNetworks’ Rhapsody, charge their users a monthly fee. Napster users, for example, pay $9.95 a month for access to the service’s 700,000-song library. (Many subscription services also let their subscribers download tracks, but for an additional fee.)
It was clear which approach the music industry executives speaking at Music 2.0 favored — a session on Analyzing the Digital Distribution Revenue Models featuring speakers from Napster, RealNetworks and MSN’s fledgling music service was essentially an hour-long testimonial on behalf of subscription-based music stores. More than one speaker cited Apple’s “10,000 songs in your pocket” slogan for the iPod and asked whether shoppers would want to pay $10,000 for 10,000 downloads or $10 for monthly access to more than 10,000 songs.
“A subscription service has more variety,” said David Weinberg, vice president of business development and business affairs for Universal Music’s eLabs.
It also has a rosier long-term revenue outlook, at least according to some of the Music 2.0 speakers. Jupiter Media Metrix predicts that the revenue from subscription-based online music services will overtake revenue from music downloads; RealNetworks Chief Strategy Office Richard Wolpert told Music 2.0 attendees he believes that will happen in 2006.
While subscription services were held up as the ideal model, Apple’s approach came under fire from rival companies. “Selling 99-cent singles isn’t working,” said David Goldberg, vice president and general manager for music at Yahoo. “They’re selling a lot of iPods. Apple is doing a great job… [but] as a model for [selling to] kids, it’s not a workable model.”
To Subscribe or Not to Subscribe
It’s clear how music sellers benefit from a subscription-based model — those monthly fees provide a steady, predictable source of revenue. But what’s in it for users? There’s the variety offered by access to an entire library of streaming music — but what if you’re more inclined to listen to specific genres and artists instead of a wide variety? In that instance, a subscription music service becomes more like paying for a package of 80 cable TV channels when you only watch eight.
There’s also the issue of portability — yes, you can receive streaming music from a vast library when you’re at your PC, but how do you take that music on the road? (Subscription-based services think they may have this problem licked: Windows Media Digital Rights Management 10 software from Microsoft lets users transfer subscription-based content to compatible music players.)
But for music users used to downloading songs from the iTunes Music Store directly to their hard drives, the biggest question surrounding subscription services may be one of ownership. What happens to the music you’ve been paying to hear once you’re no longer a subscriber?
So competitors may be lining up to take on Apple. But pardon the company if it’s not exactly fretting about the growing number of subscription services gunning for its business. “We think the holiday quarter is just going to be an exceptional one,” Apple’s Bell told Music 2.0 attendees.
And the company’s confidence is well earned, observers say. “Steve Jobs made buying music online cool,” said Ted Cohen, EMI Recorded Music’s senior vice president of digital development and distribution. “Some people, without being specific, are just relying on brand strength. ‘We’re so and so, so they’ll come.'”
Apple tangles with owner of itunes.co.uk
U.K.-based Internet entrepreneur Benjamin Cohen says that he got an unexpected shock last month after he checked his voicemail and heard a lawyer representing Apple Computer Inc. telling him to hand over his Web site domain, itunes.co.uk. Apple alleges that Cohen’s CyberBritain Holdings Ltd is a “cybersquatter” just sitting on the domain hoping for a big settlement; Cohen denies the allegation.
Apple pitches music industry on U2-style promos
U2 has been a familiar sight to iTunes Music Store visitors in recent weeks, with the online music store featuring everything from a U2-themed iPod to a digital boxed set of the Irish rock band’s recordings. And if Apple has its way, other musical acts will enjoy a similar promotional push as part of an effort to bolster business at the online store, the director of iTunes product marketing told a gathering of music industry executives Wednesday.
Apple launches new Start Page for new Web users
Oracle deploys Xserve RAID internally
Consumer Reports gives Apple high marks
U.S. iTunes Music Store now accepts PayPal
Will analysts stick with Apple this time?
Survey: Napster, iTunes beat other download brands
Playlist: iPod Gift Week: Stocking Stuffers
It’s that time of year: the holidays. A time when many people find themselves scrambling to find gifts for their loved ones — hopefully, gifts those loved ones will actually use. If the object of your yuletide affection is an iPod owner, we’re here to help with a week full of suggestions for some of our favorite iPod presents — presents guaranteed to elicit a reaction far more positive than “Oh, gee, another sweater. And so garishly colored too! Thanks awfully…”
Roku offers SoundBridge M500 network music player
Palo Alto, Calif.-based Roku on Wednesday introduced the SoundBridge M500, a new network music player that’s compatible with Macs and PCs. The new device has been created as a low-cost player that can play music from a computer to an audio system by streaming data over a wired or wireless network.
Troll Touch adds touchscreen to 17-inch PowerBook
Sonnet debuts two 1.7GHz G4 upgrades, drops prices
DLO TransPod now compatible with iPod photo
FW Depot ships FW800 Dual 3.5″ ATA enclosure
Giga issues 1.7GHz SP, DP G4 upgrades
Contour Design intros hard case for iPod photo
Dual DVD, HD-DVD disc developed
Workgroup Videohub adds HD-SD downconversion, more
Miglia AlchemyTV supports webcasting via Wirecast
PowerStick juices up iPod battery
New GameSpy terms threaten Mac to PC online gaming
New software licensing fees dictated by GameSpy Industries Inc. may make it impossible for Mac game publishers to let their forthcoming games play against their PC counterparts. GameSpy’s licensing fees have increased by a factor of five to ten in recent months, an amount that Mac game publishers say is unreasonable to expect them to pay.
SimDriveline released for automotive designers
Thunderbird 1.0 takes on Entourage, Eudora
AMG ships two new Apple Loops CDs
NI Komplete Care bundles all 2005 updates
QuickMail Server 3.5.1 adds Spamcaster, more
Nicecast adds full custom MP3 settings, more
Aspyr: Doom 3 reaches beta
Auto.des.sys now shipping form.Z 5.0
Around the Web
China’s Lenovo to buy IBM’s PC business
China’s Lenovo Group Ltd. signed a definitive agreement on Wednesday to acquire IBM Corp.’s personal computing division. Lenovo will pay US$1.25 billion in cash for the business, which is expected to transform it into the world’s number three PC maker, the companies announced.
Tool Time at Pixar
Apple to use Toshiba chip next year
Security issues plague Windows PCs, not Macs
How many iPods will Apple sell next year?
Player can’t hit the high notes
Mac installed base set to grow again
What are you getting your iPod?