Review: LaCie Hard Disk Designed by Neil Poulton 1TB
From the Lab
By James Galbraith
At a Glance
Speedy eSATA connection
Fan noise may be bothersome
The LaCie Hard Disk Designed by Neil Poulton is a desktop hard drive that can connect to your Mac via FireWire 400, USB 2.0, or eSATA. It features an interesting design-a shiny black rectangular box with sharp corners, and a blue activity light located on the lower front of the drive that reflects off of your desktop. The drive uses a 1TB, 3.5-inch, 7,200 RPM mechanism, and requires external power to operate.
Many external hard drives we’ve tested lately feature aluminum cases which act as heat sinks, allowing the drives to operate quietly without a constantly whirring fan. The Neil Poulton drive, however, uses a plastic case and does require a fan. It’s not terribly loud, but even with the air conditioning, office chatter (“Can you please hold it down, people, I’m trying to work here!”) and multiple Macs running in the lab, the fan is audible. If you have a microphone nearby, like the one built into a MacBook, the mic will pick up the fan noise.
We tested the drive using all three connections, and the Neil Poulton drive posted results comparable to other desktop hard drives we tested, such as LaCie’s d2 Quadra (). When comparing the performance between the Neil Poulton drive’s different connections, we found, as expected, USB 2.0 to be the slowest connection, with times that were 6 to 20 percent slower than FireWire 400. The fastest performance was in our eSATA trials, with times that were 20 to 57 percent faster than FireWire 400. Unfortunately, no Macs ship with built in eSATA support, so an expansion card needs to be installed in either your Mac Pro or MacBook Pro in order to use that fast connection.
The drive ships with LaCie’s 1-Click Backup Software, and it also supports Apple’s Time Machine backup utility. We were able to use the drive as a boot drive when connected to a Mac Pro using USB or FireWire.
Copy 1GB file to FireWire 400
Copy 1GB file to USB 2.0
Copy 1GB file to eSATA
Duplicate 1GB file via FireWire 400
Duplicate 1GB file via USB 2.0
Duplicate 1GB file via eSATA
Low-memory Photoshop: FireWire 400
Low-memory Photoshop: USB 2.0
Low-memory Photoshop: eSATA
Times are in minutes:seconds
How we tested. We ran all tests with drives connected to a Mac Pro Quad 2.66GHz Xeon with Mac OS X 10.5 installed and 1GB of RAM. We tested the drive with each available port—FireWire 400, USB 2, and eSATA. We copied a folder containing 1GB of data from our Mac’s hard drive to the external hard drive to test the drive’s write speed. We then duplicated that file on the external drive to test both read and write speeds. We also used the drive as a scratch disk when running our low-memory Adobe Photoshop CS3 Suite test. This test is a set of four tasks performed on a 150MB file, with Photoshop’s memory set to 25 percent.—Macworld Lab Testing by James Galbraith and Jerry Jung
Price per gigabyte
eSATA (1), FW400 (1), USB 2.0 (1)
Macworld’s buying advice
The LaCie Hard Disk Designed by Neil Poulton offers multiple connection options, zippy eSATA performance and a striking design. If you are sensitive to noise, you may want to look for a fanless hard drive. If not, the Neil Poulton drive is a versatile drive worthy of consideration.
[James Galbraith is Macworld‘s lab director.]
Note: When you purchase something after clicking links in our articles, we may earn a small commission. Read ouraffiliate link policyfor more details.