Review: Buffalo MiniStation TurboUSB Portable Hard Drive 500GB
From the Lab
By Chris Holt, MacworldJAN 21, 2009 10:05 pm PST
At a Glance
Increased data transfer speeds when used with Tiger and TurboUSB driver
TurboUSB driver doesn’t offer speed boost with latest version of Mac OS X
With the lack of FireWire ports in the current
MacBook () and
MacBook Air (), USB-only drives have re-emerged as attractive storage options for Mac users. The 500GB
MiniStation TurboUSB Portable Hard Drive is a humble-looking workhorse of a drive, with modestly fast USB speed—if you’re using Mac OS 10.4 (Tiger)—and the added security of being physically tougher than your average portable drive.
The USB-only MiniStation is a durable little black brick. Equipped with a shock-resistant shell, it can survive more falls, drops, and bumps than your average drive, ensuring that your data remains safely stored inside. The few times I purposely dropped the drive from my desk to floor, the drive performed no worse for the wear. It’s about as small as your standard external drive and its appearance is similarly benign, but the MiniStation allows for you to easily wrap up its cord for increased portability. The drive doesn’t come with or need an AC power adapter; it can draw power from the USB connection.
As a USB-only device with a 4,200 rpm hard drive mechanism, the MiniStation won’t reach the data transfer speeds of drives equipped with FireWire or eSATA connections. It will, however, work on most current computers, although you will need the USB power adapter cord included with the drive in order to use it with older PowerBooks.
While Buffalo’s press materials tout increased connection speeds when using the included TurboUSB software driver, our test results showed otherwise when running Mac OS X 10.5 (Leopard). TurboUSB didn’t make a difference in two of our three tests, with the duplication test being the one only to see any benefit. In our time trials, the MiniStation finished our 1GB copy test in approximately 52 seconds, with and without the TurboUSB driver. The low-memory Photoshop test was barely improved by the TurboUSB drivers; the average time of 1 minute and 37 seconds is in the realm of what we’ve seen from other external hard drives using USB. Our Duplication Test improved by 4 seconds when using the TurboUSB driver.
Does this mean that TurboUSB is a bogus technology? Not necessarily. Buffalo says that the TurboUSB driver is meant for use with Mac OS 10.4, and that users who are running Leopard won’t see a significant improvement in transfer speeds. We found that on a Mac running Tiger, the TurboUSB drivers will improve your scores dramatically. The MiniStation saw a 25 percent increase in our 1GB copy test, and a 20 percent boost in our duplication test, though even without the benefit of TurboUSB, our Leopard scores were higher across the board.
The MiniStation’s 500GB capacity, though not unique, is the highest available for single-mechanism portable drives. Priced currently at $170, the Buffalo drive has a $0.34 cents per gigabyte ratio, besting even Toshiba’s
USB 2.0 Portable External Hard Drive 400GB () $0.45 cents per gigabyte price. The MiniStation is also available in 320GB, 250GB, 160GB, and 120GB capacities.
Copy 1GB file to USB 2.0
Duplicate 1GB file via USB 2.0
Low-memory Photoshop: USB 2.0
Scale = minutes:seconds
How we tested. We ran all tests with drives connected to a Mac Pro Quad 2.66GHz Xeon with Mac OS X 10.5 installed and 1GB of RAM. We tested the drive with each available port. We copied a folder containing 1GB of data from our Mac’s hard drive to the external hard drive to test the drive’s write speed. We then duplicated that file on the external drive to test both read and write speeds. We also used the drive as a scratch disk when running our low-memory Adobe Photoshop CS3 Suite test. This test is a set of four tasks performed on a 150MB file, with Photoshop’s memory set to 25 percent—Macworld Lab Testing by Chris Holt
Macworld’s buying advice
If you’re looking for a USB-only drive, you could do a lot worse than the Buffalo MiniStation. The shock-resistant shell makes it better engineered for travel than competing drives, but its speed is underwhelming. Ultimately, though, if you’re buying a USB-only drive, speed isn’t as big a concern as safety, a convenient size, and portability—three features the MiniStation has in spades.