Adobe said on Monday that it will release its first full-fledged Flash multimedia player for smartphones by year’s end.
Google, Microsoft, Palm, and
Nokia are all expected to release platforms or phones next year that will be able to display the same videos and applications as the most recent Flash 10 player for desktop computers, says Adobe.
Adobe will demonstrate the Flash Player 10 for smartphones beta at this week’s Mobile World Congress in Barcelona.
But Adobe said that it was still not close to delivering
Flash players that would work with Apple’s iPhone or Research in Motion’s
And analysts are divided on whether that will ever happen.
Adobe has been
working on a Flash player tailored for the iPhone for almost a year, after Apple CEO Steve Jobs
complained about Flash’s performance on the
“We’ve made a lot of progress, but there is still a lot of engineering work to be done,” said Anup Murarka, director of partner development and technology strategy for Adobe’s platform business unit.
Adobe has optimized Flash’s performance on the ARM v6 CPU used by the iPhone, and the Arm v7 to be used by
the upcoming Palm Pre.
“We’re working with
Apple on what we have,” Murarka said. “We’re committed to make the Flash plug-in work on the iPhone.”
Adobe is at an even earlier stage with RIM.
“We’ve had some initial conversations and are evaluating different approaches to be taken,” Murarka said. “There is a lot of interest from BlackBerry enterprise customers to be able to build Flash apps. But there is no working solution yet.”
Stewart Robinson, an analyst with Strategy Analytics in the U.K., is optimistic that with Adobe “working frantically behind the scenes to get Flash onto the iPhone … it will happen, but not until much later this year.”
But Jack Gold, an independent analyst with J. Gold Associates, is less optimistic, for two reasons.
One is technical. “Adobe wants Flash to run really well. To get high performance, you need to run in the lower layers of the OS or phone,” Gold said. Windows Mobile, Nokia’s Symbian and Googles Android are relatively open to that, but OSes such as those on the BlackBerry and iPhone are not, he said.
The other reason, at least with Apple, is business. “Apple wants to push its own technology, in this case, QuickTime,” Gold said. “It has its own interests at heart. Look at how long it took to get Flash onto Macs. I honestly don’t think you will see Flash on the iPhone anytime soon.”
Adobe said last fall that it would bring a browser-based version of the full Flash player to smartphones for the first time.
The company has long developed a
cut-down version of Flash, Flash Lite, for regular cellphones and their more powerful smartphone brethren.
Flash Lite is
said to be spreading like wildfire , according to third-party statistics released by Adobe today.
Feature-wise, Flash Lite lags behind the desktop version of Flash by several years, especially with multimedia streaming features..
Jobs’ criticism, combined with the increased power of modern smartphones, motivated Adobe to bring a full Flash player to smartphones.
Such mobile computing power also allows developers to bring applications they have written to run for Flash on a PC to a smartphone with fewer compromises.
To further encourage this, Adobe and Nokia plan to give away $10 million to developers with ideas for Flash services and applications that can run on a smartphone as well as TV set-top boxes and PCs. (Developers can apply at
the Open Screen Project Fund’s Web site.
With more applications, Flash compatibility may become increasingly attractive to holdouts such as RIM and Apple.