A federal judge is now considering whether to permit sales of RealDVD, after testimony on a pretrial injunction ended Thursday. That injunction has prevented RealNetworks from selling its DVD software since late September.
Judge Marilyn Patel, who also presided over the Napster case in 2001, will decide whether to keep RealDVD off the market pending the outcome of a lawsuit brought by the movie industry. Plaintiffs’ lawyers claim the software can be used to make illegal copies of films and that it violates the Digital Millennium Copyright Act’s prohibition on anti-circumvention technology.
case has pitted the technology industry against the major movie studios in a fight over
who gets to control how digital movies are used.
RealNetworks introduced RealDVD in September, but sales were quickly halted by the injunction granted when movie studios filed suit. The software lets users copy and play movies from their computer hard drives, much the way Apple’s iTunes works with CDs. The motion picture studios worry that the software could be misused, however.
DVD copying software such as
Handbrake has been widely available since the Content-Scrambling System (CSS) used to copy-protect DVDs was cracked a decade ago, but RealNetworks had been trying to walk the line between enforcing copy protection and giving users a way to store movies on their computers.
In court testimony late last month, RealNetworks CEO Rob Glaser had argued that scofflaws are unlikely to use RealDVD, which costs $30 and prevents users from burning new DVDs of their movies. There are “dozens of products” that DVD pirates could use if they wanted to make illegal copies, he told the court. “All you have to do is Google DVD ripper.“
Real was sued by Disney, Paramount, Sony, Twentieth Century Fox, NBC Universal, Warner Brothers, Viacom on Sept. 30, 2008. It filed a countersuit the same day. The DVD Copy Control Association, which licenses the CSS system, is also involved in the case. The case is being heard in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California in San Francisco.
After Judge Patel decides whether or not to continue blocking sales of RealDVD, the case will then move toward trial. The judge’s ruling could come at any time.