When playing Blu-ray discs, the BD-P1600 sent very good but not spectacular images to our HDTV. Its best performance came in its handling of the opening sequence of the animated movie Cars, where it delivered vibrant, saturated colors.
On the other hand, the BD-P1600 didn’t fare well with standard-definition DVDs, which the player must upconvert to 1080p.
Another issue: This model has a big flap over its front panel; the flap swings open when you eject the tray, and it stays open until you remember to close it, meanwhile posing a scrape hazard to anyone who walks past the player too closely.
The remote was disappointing, too: Many important buttons (such as the ones for Play, Pause, and the disc menu) are well placed but too small, while the setup button is quite large. The remote isn’t backlit.
Macworld’s buying advice
The BD-P1600 offers a relatively inexpensive way to add network streaming services, and it produces solid images; but you may find this unit’s design frustrating.
[Lincoln Spector is a contributing editor to PC World.]