A big problem with iCloud Drive’s Desktop and Documents Folders synchronization feature is that, by default, iCloud Drive automatically deletes local copies of files when you start running out of storage—by whatever definition of “running out of storage” macOS internally relies upon. The file still appears to be available, but it’s in iCloud, and if you want to access it, macOS downloads it when you try to open or otherwise manipulate it.
Because any given file could be deleted, you can’t make a full local or cloud-based backup separate from iCloud of all your files. This means you’re relying entirely on Apple, and if you had a problem with your Apple ID or iCloud account, you could wind up losing access to files or having to go through a tedious problem to regain them. (I covered this issue recently as a more general issue in “ Why you shouldn’t rely on iCloud Drive as your only backup.”)
However, there’s a way to avoid this, so long as you have enough storage. In the iCloud system preference pane, click the Options button next to iCloud Drive. At the bottom of the Documents tab’s dialog box, there’s a checkbox labeled Optimize Mac Storage. When this box is checked, which is the default option when enabling iCloud Drive, macOS deletes files as need be. This applies to all iCloud Drive files, including items you place in the folder, apps that use iCloud Drive (and have their box checked in the Documents tab’s list), and Desktop and Documents Folders.
But if you uncheck the box, all files remain stored locally. This does defeat one of the major points of the feature, which is managing storage automatically. Since I disagree with that feature from a backup standpoint, I think this is dandy. Your opinion may differ.
The other main benefit of iCloud Drive sync is making these files available in iCloud Drive on other Macs, in iOS, and via iCloud.com.
If you’re going to use the option for sync, I highly recommend disabling Optimize Mac Storage. If you have multiple Macs, you should disable it on all of them—but first be sure that you have sufficient storage on each Mac to handle the full Desktop and Documents folders combined of all your Macs.
Ask Mac 911
We’ve compiled a list of the questions we get asked most frequently along with answers and links to columns: read our super FAQ to see if your question is covered. If not, we’re always looking for new problems to solve! Email yours to firstname.lastname@example.org screen captures as appropriate, and whether you want your full name used. Every question won’t be answered, we don’t reply to email, and we cannot provide direct troubleshooting advice.