Here’s a question we don’t receive often at Macworld, but it’s one to ponder. Rajeevan asks:
I don’t own an Apple device currently, and I am operating my Apple account and mail from a Windows computer. Now how can I enable two-factor authentication from my Windows 10 computer and generate an app-specific password?
This question likely popped up because of Apple’s decision to end third-party access to calendars, contacts, and email without using two-factor authentication (2FA) for your Apple ID/iCloud account and generating an app-specific password. You can read a column from May for more details.
Rajeevan has a real problem. Apple only allows 2FA to be turned on from a Mac or iOS device. Once enabled, you can use SMS text messaging or computer-synthesized voice calls for confirmation codes, and the Apple ID site for managing app-specific passwords. (In fact, you can’t create app-specific passwords except at the site, which seems odd.)
This requires priming the pump. My best suggestion is that Rajeevan finds a friend, relative, or colleague who would let them create an account on a Mac that was used solely to set up 2FA. After creating an account on that Mac, logging in, and enabling 2FA, that macOS account would likely never be needed again! And Apple doesn’t track Mac and iOS logins to your Apple ID—that’s not a requirement at present. (It’s possible at some future point, Apple would make you log in with the Apple ID either on an iOS device or a Mac, and you’d have to a find a friend to make that happen. But for now, just the setup stage is all that’s required.)
Apple lets you set up multiple trusted phone numbers as well as having at least one trusted device. The device will be that Mac (and specifically, your account on that Mac). But you could run into trouble if you only set up a single phone number for your 2FA confirmation codes and then you lose access to that number. In that case, you might be unable to log into the Apple ID site to add another trusted number, and would have to use the Mac on which you set up an account to verify yourself and change your settings.
For that reason, you might add a friend or relative’s phone number (with their permission) as one or more additional ways to get a code.
Ask Mac 911
We’ve compiled a list of the questions we get asked most frequently along with answers and links to columns: read our super FAQ to see if your question is covered. If not, we’re always looking for new problems to solve! Email yours to email@example.com including screen captures as appropriate. Mac 911 can’t reply to—nor publish an answer to—every question, and we don’t provide direct troubleshooting advice.