Upcoming mistakes: Pre-dooming the HomePod


Today's Best Tech Deals

Picked by Macworld's Editors

Top Deals On Great Products

Picked by Techconnect's Editors

No Apple product arrives un-doomed and the HomePod is no exception.

Writing for The Motley Fool, Rich Duprey brings us yet another edition of “Just Askin’!”, the new game show that literally nobody likes.

“Will This Be Apple’s Biggest Mistake Since the Newton?”

Since the Newton?! Wow! That is a famous product that Apple made that did not achieve substantial success! Gosh, good pull there. Surely no one has referenced the Newton in the context of Apple failures in, er, probably a couple of days.

The Cupertino giant rarely makes a misstep, but when it does, it’s usually dramatic.

And dates to the Clinton administration.

Amazon.com and Alphabet’s Google are far ahead in the field of voice assistants…

People love to say that. It certainly does seem like Amazon and Google’s assistants are better than Siri at certain things, but it’s debatable as to how much better. And, once again, the only instance of the word “privacy” on the page delivering this article is the link to The Motley Fool’s privacy policy.

The Macalope doesn’t get why privacy simply is not an issue worth even mentioning for a huge swath of the people covering this stuff, but that is apparently the case.

…and Apple’s failures are allowing them to sprint forward without any checks on their growth.

Apple’s only failure here is most likely just a failure to really care that much. Selling devices close to cost in order to maximize e-commerce sales or advertising revenue isn’t a business Apple wants to be in.

Duprey also manages to neglect to mention this:

“Amazon has big plans for Alexa ads in 2018; it’s discussing options with P&G, Clorox and others.”

“People in your demographic are eating a lot of Tide Pods these days. Did you know you can subscribe and save through Amazon Pantry?”

Amazon said the Echo Dot was the No. 1 selling product on the e-commerce site this Christmas, with all Alexa-enabled devices selling tens of millions of units worldwide.

You know what sells in the scores of millions every quarter and comes with Siri? iPhones.

It’s clear the smart home is finally upon us…

Is it? Because let us, through the magic of time travel, jump down a few paragraphs, shall we?

Adobe Analytics says that voice assistants are not a widely adopted device, and consumers still need to be convinced they need one.


Duprey down low: Eh, not a lot of people actually have these things yet.

As the saying goes, he who hesitates is lost, and while letting the competition beat it to the punch with their devices is bad enough, Apple is committing another forced error by also reportedly keeping the HomePod’s ecosystem closed to developers.

Just like how the iPhone started and look how that turned out. TERRIBLE.

Where Amazon and Google cut the price of their devices to under $30 for the holiday season to entice as many people as possible to buy them, Apple remains steadfast in its determination to sell the HomePod for $350.

The Macalope personally thinks the HomePod and the Apple TV are overpriced. But, again, if this is a race to the bottom to pave the world in cheap pieces of crap like netbooks or Brand Z tablets, that’s a game Apple doesn’t want or need to play.

The Macalope really doesn’t know if the HomePod will be a good product. Partially because the darn thing hasn’t even been released yet. But we’ve heard this “Apple is too late to the market” spiel before—with the iPod, the iPhone and the Apple Watch—and the horny one is not inclined to be very worried this time, either.

Note: When you purchase something after clicking links in our articles, we may earn a small commission. Read our affiliate link policy for more details.
Shop Tech Products at Amazon