How Messages in the Cloud protects SMS (and how it doesn’t)

iphone x messages
IDG

Apple recently released the long-awaited Messages in the Cloud feature through updates to iOS and macOS, and Macworld provided a how-to guide to enable it on your devices, and some warnings about the time it takes for your devices to upload all the cached messages they maintain.

Macworld reader Lowell had a few questions that aren’t on the how-to front and which Apple doesn’t fully address in its FAQ on the subject.

Lowell wonders about regular text and multimedia messages (SMS/MMS) being encrypted, and how much storage is freed up in iCloud (not just on devices) by pushing everything to the cloud.

Messages in the Cloud uses end-to-end encryption, just like iCloud Keychain. While your messages are centrally stored in iCloud and synced via it to your devices, there’s no way to retrieve message at iCloud.com, just as with iCloud Keychain. Apple encrypts the data so that even it can’t decrypt it.

SMS and MMS messages you receive in Messages on any platform are synced and secured the same way. However, it’s critical to note that text messages aren’t secured on the cellular network. It’s not trivial, but neither is it impossible to intercept text messages being sent to you. Once they’re received, however, and in the Messages ecosystem, they just as secure as iMessages. (iMessages are always encrypted end to end, so there’s no issue there.)

On the storage side, Apple notes that consolidating messages means that you’re saving space on each device, as like with other iCloud services, each device doesn’t need a full copy—you can retrieve and search back messages that are synced via iCloud through Messages on any of your devices.

However, Lowell wondered how this affects iCloud backups for iOS, which by default do make a copy of each iOS device’s locally cache Messages archives. Messages in the Cloud does reduce that storage as well, which can be significant. I’ve seen my own and other devices each allocate gigabytes towards Messages, although it wasn’t always clear if that was an accurate count or all messages data and associated attachments.

However, given the very low free tier of 5GB for iCloud, it’s unlikely with two devices you’d be able to be under that total in any case. The next tier is 50GB, and a few gigabytes probably won’t help much there, either.

Ask Mac 911

We’ve compiled a list of the questions we get asked most frequently along with answers and links to columns: read our super FAQ to see if your question is covered. If not, we’re always looking for new problems to solve! Email yours to mac911@macworld.com including screen captures as appropriate, and whether you want your full name used. Every question won’t be answered, we don’t reply to email, and we cannot provide direct troubleshooting advice.

  
Shop Tech Products at Amazon