iPhone XR vs iPhone XS and iPhone XS Max: Which one should you buy?

How does the iPhone XR stack up to the XS and XS Max? You may be surprised.

apple iphone xs xr lineup
Apple

Just like last year, Apple announced three new iPhone models, but it’s not so easy to tell them apart anymore. Gone is the old-school design with the home button and the giant bezels, and in its place are three new models with iPhone X styling. (But don’t worry, if you really like the old look, you can still buy an iPhone 8 or 8 Plus.)

If you’re having trouble deciding which model to buy, we feel your indecision. That’s why we created this handy guide to help you sort it all out.

iPhone XR vs iPhone XS and iPhone XS Max: Size

apple event xs max compared Apple

All three new models of iPhone have Apple’s new “all-screen” design that dispenses of the superfluous space above and below the screen and pushes the display all the way to the edges. It also means you’ll have to deal with a notch at the the top for the camera and other sensors, which cuts down on the physical size.

  • iPhone XS: 143.6 x 70.9 x 7.7mm
  • iPhone XS Max: 157.5 x 77.4 x 7.7mm
  • iPhone XR: 150.9 x 75.7 x 8.3mm

For comparison, the iPhone 8 Plus measures 158.4 x 78.1 x 7.5mm, so even the largest 6.5-inch iPhone isn’t any bigger than the previous generation, despite having an inch more of screen space.

iPhone XR vs iPhone XS and iPhone XS Max: Display

Here’s where things start to get weird. The iPhone XS has the same 5.8-inch display as the iPhone X, but now there’s a new model, the 6.5-inch iPhone XS Max. Both of those screens use Apple’s new OLED display tech for “the most accurate color in the industry, HDR, and true blacks.”

At the low end, Apple has made an entirely new phone, the iPhone XR, which brings a 6.1-inch LCD screen that Apple is calling Liquid Retina, so its actually bigger than the 5.8-inch iPhone XS. Here’s how the three models shake out.

  • iPhone XS: 5.8-inch OLED, 2436x1125, 458 ppi
  • iPhone XS Max: 6.5-inch OLED, 2688x1242, 458 ppi
  • iPhone XR: 6.1-inch LCD, 1792x828, 326 ppi

The resolution of the iPhone XR is clearly lower than the XS, but it might not be as terrible as it looks. For comparison, the 4.8-inch iPhone 8 has a resolution of 1334x750 at 326 ppi, so the screen will likely pale in comparison to the iPhone XS and XS Max. Still, Apple defines Retina quality as anything with a pixel density above 300, so you still shouldn’t see any jagged edges. All three displays feature Apple’s True Tone technology and have a 625 cd/m2 max brightness.

iPhone XR vs iPhone XS and iPhone XS Max: Performance

apple event a12 specs1 Apple

Like last year, Apple isn’t pulling any punches when it comes to performance. All three phones are powered by the new A12 Bionic processor, which Apple describes as “the smartest, most powerful chip in a smartphone.” It includes a new neural engine able to perform five trillion operations per second for AR and camera advancements, as well as a faster and more efficient CPU and GPU. There’s also 4GB of RAM in the XS models versus 3GB in the XR, so that should help with multitasking and app launching.

iPhone XR vs iPhone XS and iPhone XS Max: Battery

Apple doesn’t like to disclose the exact capacity of its battery (not until iFixit gets its hands not the new phones anyway), but here’s what Apple has to say about the new models.

  • iPhone XS: Lasts up to 30 minutes longer than iPhone X
  • iPhone XS Max: Lasts up to 1.5 hours longer than iPhone X
  • iPhone XR: Lasts up to 1.5 hours longer than iPhone 8 Plus

Since that’s kind of meaningless, here are some actual battery estimates.

  • iPhone XS: Up to 12 hours of internet use and 14 hours of video playback
  • iPhone XS Max: Up to 13 hours of internet use and 15 hours of video playback
  • iPhone XR: Up to 15 hours of internet use and 16 hours of video playback

And finally, regulatory filings have provided actual battery capacities for the three phones:

  • iPhone XS: 2,658mAh (versus 2,716mAh on the iPhone X)
  • iPhone XS Max: 3,174mAh
  • iPhone XR: 2,942mAh (versus 2,675 on the iPhone 8 Plus)

Based on those estimates and capacities, the iPhone XR is the clear leader, but all three should get you through a full day of use. In our review, we found the iPhone XS Max lasted about an hour longer than the iPhone XS, but obviously, that depends on usage.

iPhone XR vs iPhone XS and iPhone XS Max: Rear camera

iphone xr rear camera Apple

The iPhone XS and XS Max both have the exact same dual camera setup, while the iPhone XR has a single camera like the iPhone 8.

iPhone XS/XS Max: Dual 12MP wide-angle (f/1.8) and telephoto cameras (f/2.4), dual optical image stabilization, 2x optical zoom
iPhone XR: 12MP (f/1.8), optical image stabilization

As you can see, the camera array on the iPhone XS and XS Max is vastly superior to the iPhone XR, but the main lens is actually the same on all three models. We’ll have to wait to see how that translates to real-world shooting. Even without the second camera, however, you will still get Portrait Mode with advanced bokeh and Depth Control, Portrait Lighting, and Smart HDR, as well as 4K video recording and slo-mo video support for 1080p at 120 fps or 240 fps.

iPhone XR vs iPhone XS and iPhone XS Max: Front camera

The front camera is the same on all three devices: 7MP TrueDepth camera with f/2.2 aperture. They all include Portrait Mode, Portrait Lighting, and Smart HDR.

iPhone XR vs iPhone XS and iPhone XS Max: Biometrics

iphone xr rain shot Apple

Since the home button has been removed, all three phones include Face ID for unlocking. Apple says the system has been tuned to be faster, and with iOS 12, you’ll be able to add a second face as well.

iPhone XR vs iPhone XS and iPhone XS Max: Storage

Apple has added a third storage options to the iPhone lineup, but you have different options on the iPhone XR compared to the two XS models.

  • iPhone XS: 64GB/256GB/512GB
  • iPhone XS Max: 64GB/256GB/512GB
  • iPhone XR: 64GB/128GB/256GB

The iPhone XS models both max out at 512GB, the most storage Apple has ever offered in a phone. The iPhone XR has the same 256GB that the iPhone 8 offered at the high end, but adds a new 128GB tier in the middle. Half-a-terabyte is nice and all, but most people won’t have any reason for that much internal storage.

iPhone XR vs iPhone XS and iPhone XS Max: Charging

All three iPhones feature wireless charging, but you’ll need to buy a third-party pad, since AirPower is still MIA.

Sadly, all three phones ship with the same 5W charger, so you’ll need to buy a $49 30W charger along with a $19 USB-C-to-Lightning cable to get fast charging.

iPhone XR vs iPhone XS and iPhone XS Max: Colors

iphone xr colors Apple

Where last year’s iPhone X only came in black and silver, Apple has greatly expanded its palette this year.

  • iPhone XS: Black, silver, gold
  • iPhone XS Max: Black, silver, gold
  • iPhone XR: White, black, blue, yellow, coral, gold, (Product) RED

iPhone XR vs iPhone XS and iPhone XS Max: Price

Here’s the moment you’ve all been waiting for: What do these things cost? While none of the new iPhones start as low as the $699 iPhone 8, there should be a new iPhone for every budget, assuming you have lots of money to spend on a new phone.

  • iPhone XS: $999/$1,149/$1,349
  • iPhone XS Max: $1,099/$1,249/$1,449
  • iPhone XR: $749/$799/$899

iPhone XR vs iPhone XS vs iPhone XS Max: Availability

The iPhone XS and XS Max are available for purchase now through all four major carriers, Best Buy, and Apple.com. The iPhone XR is slightly delayed, with pre-orders beginning Friday, October 19 and shipping a week later, on October 26.

iPhone XR vs iPhone XS vs iPhone XS Max: Which should you buy

If you absolutely have to have the best of the best, then the iPhone XS Max is for you. It’s not cheap, but it has the biggest screen Apple has ever made, with lots of RAM, a big battery, tons of storage. The smaller iPhone XS is a great phone too, based on early reviews, but the decision to buy there is a little murkier. For one, the difference between it and the iPhone XS Max is only $100 and you get way more pixels on the bigger phone. But the biggest question is over the iPhone XR. We haven’t had a chance to look at the phone yet, and since it costs $250 less for the same processor, main camera, and longer battery life, it’s probably a good idea to wait.

  
Shop Tech Products at Amazon